Supernatural (& Destiel)
That range of expressions pretty succinctly sums up my feelings about Castiel in the show and fandom: Yay... It's Castiel... Everywhere... All the time... Great... Can we just give him a spin-off, already? The SPN fans get the show back, and the MishAmigos get their own solid forty-five of Cas a week. Hell, Dean can be the costar... And then, in S4, we introduce Sam, who drives a wedge between them at a moment when they're at their lowest, and suddenly Dean and this new guy take over the fandom.